How to Influence in a 1:1: Tips for Managers and Employees
Shape your 1:1 from both sides
A 1:1 is a regular conversation between a manager and one member of their team. Done well, it’s one of the most valuable influence moments in the working week. Done badly, it slides into a status update that both people quietly dread.
And both people in the room can shape it, not just the manager.
In this article we’ll look at the 1:1 from both sides: what managers can do, what employees can do, and what changes when both people take ownership.
Why so many 1:1s drift
In a lot of 1:1s, each person is quietly waiting for the other one to lead. The manager sees it as the employee’s time. The employee sees it as the manager’s meeting. So nobody really steers it, and it drifts into updates, or gets cancelled when things get busy.
I’ve been on the wrong end of this. When I worked in recruitment, we had an interim manager join the business. He was going through a tough time, and I don’t think his focus or responsibilities were in the right place. Our 1:1s felt very much like the cart pulling the horse: there was no preparation from his side, so I ended up doing the pulling. They were also very transactional, focused only on short-term activity, with nothing about me personally or the long-term strategic goals of the business. It felt like a useless tick-box exercise, and I always left feeling frustrated and confused.
Knowing what I know now, I would’ve been more courageous and asked for more structure, or at least got aligned on an agenda ahead of each 1:1, so it was a valuable use of both our time.
The fix isn’t a longer meeting or a smarter template. It’s both people deciding, on purpose, to use the time well.
For managers: 5 ways to make your 1:1s count
1. Let them go first
Start with their agenda, not yours. What’s on someone’s mind tells you what matters to them right now, and what will move them. Your points will land better once theirs have been heard.
2. Ask more than you tell
One question can change the whole meeting: “What’s getting in your way?” Questions surface problems while they’re still small, and people tend to own the solutions they help shape.
3. Flex to their style
Some people want detail. Some want pace. Some need to feel safe before they open up. One approach rarely fits a whole team, so notice what each person needs and adjust.
4. Protect the time
Cancelling a 1:1 sends a message, even when you don’t mean it to. Trust is built in small, consistent moments, and turning up regularly is one of them.
5. Speak last
Listen fully before you add your view. It’s harder than it sounds, and it’s one of the quickest ways to find out what’s really going on.
For employees: 5 ways to influence your manager in your 1:1
6. Bring your own agenda
If you don’t set the agenda, the meeting defaults to your manager’s. Arrive with the two or three things that matter most to you.
7. Send your top three the day before
A short note the day before gives your manager time to think, which usually means better answers and fewer “let me come back to you” moments.
8. Frame it around what they care about
What is your manager measured on? What are they under pressure on? Connecting your ask to their priorities makes it much easier for them to say yes.
9. Bring options, not just problems
“Here’s the issue, here are two ways we could fix it, and I’d suggest the first.” That’s a far easier conversation than a problem on its own, and it shows you’ve thought it through.
10. Agree one action before you leave
End with one small, clear action and who owns it. It keeps the conversation moving between meetings, and it builds momentum over time.
Want both sides on one page?
Download the free 1:1 prep card: five ideas for managers and five for employees, ready for your next conversation.
When both sides take ownership
The most useful 1:1s aren’t run by the manager or the employee. They’re shaped by both. A simple way to start is to ask each other one question at your next 1:1: “What would make these more useful for you?” It takes two minutes, and it can change the conversation for months.
Find your natural influence style
Point 3 asks managers to flex to each person’s style, which is much easier when you know your own. If you’d like to find out how you naturally influence, and where that style helps or hurts you, take the free Influence Power Index assessment.
Everyone influences. Few do it intentionally.
John Deane is a behavioural enthusiast, influence strategist and keynote speaker with 13 years experience across 25 countries.
